Everything around her is broken - her heart, her life, and even her house.

Evelyn had spent years being disappointed in her husband and their marriage. When Evelyn's husband died, leaving her pregnant and with a three-year-old, she is faced with many problems. One of them being a house in ill-repair. When the quiet and kind Hezekiah suddenly proposes, Evelyn knows this will solve her problems.

While pondering his proposal, a new Amish man visits her community and offers to fix her house. It's not long before she wonders if this man could also repair her life.

Can Evelyn put the bitter memories of her marriage behind her? Or will her fear of being alone cause her to jump feet first into another unsuitable marriage?